A disagreement over whether to keep a train door open during heavy rain ended in a fatal stabbing inside a moving Mumbai local, leaving a 22-year-old commuter dead and renewing concerns over safety on one of the world’s busiest suburban rail networks.
Police identified the victim as Mayank Lohar, who was travelling home on the Churchgate–Nallasopara Fast Local (Train No. 90663) on Tuesday night. The accused, Roshan Suvarna, 30, was arrested on Wednesday after multiple police teams tracked him using CCTV footage and technical surveillance. Reports differ on the arrest location, with authorities and media accounts placing it in either Kurla or the Panvel area.
What’s happening around the world: Rahul Gandhi seeks toughest action after police rescue 12 bonded labourers from UP factory
According to the Government Railway Police (GRP), both men boarded the train at Andheri. As heavy rain lashed Mumbai, passengers argued over whether the first-class coach door should remain open. Investigators said the confrontation escalated between Andheri and Borivali, where Suvarna allegedly pulled a knife from his bag and stabbed Lohar multiple times. Police are also examining the accused’s claim that he was assaulted by Lohar and other commuters before the stabbing.
The train reached Borivali station at about 11.04 pm. Railway staff and emergency responders entered the coach within minutes, and Lohar was taken to the emergency medical room before being shifted to Shatabdi Hospital in Kandivali, where doctors declared him dead. Investigators later reviewed footage from more than 400 CCTV cameras while tracing the suspect.
Police said Suvarna worked in the cargo division at Mumbai airport. The Indian Express reported investigators are examining whether he had consumed alcohol before boarding the train and are questioning witnesses about the sequence of events. Officers also recovered viral videos recorded inside the compartment, though investigators have not treated those clips as conclusive evidence of how the fight began.
The killing has prompted criticism from commuter groups. Siddhesh Desai, vice president of the Mumbai Rail Pravasi Sangh, said, “This incident has once again exposed the serious shortcomings in passenger security across the Mumbai Suburban Railway network”. He added that “there is no effective security screening mechanism that prevents individuals carrying knives, weapons, or other dangerous objects from entering the railway network”.
For more updates follow: First Report News
